Updated May 16, 2012 - 1:27 pm
NY inside-trading trial can feature disputed call
Originally published: May 16, 2012 - 1:27 pm
NEW YORK (AP) - A New York judge says prosecutors at an insider trading trial can play for jurors the only recording of a phone conversation between a former Goldman Sachs board member and a hedge fund founder.
Federal Judge Jed Rakoff in Manhattan made an earlier tentative ruling permanent Wednesday afternoon at a final conference before the trial of Rajat Gupta starts Monday.
Gupta was a board member at Goldman Sachs and Procter & Gamble before he was accused of giving tips in 2008 to a billionaire hedge-fund trading friend. His lawyer says he gave no inside information and expects to be exonerated at trial.
The judge left room to later limit how each side uses the 24-minute phone recording from July 2008 as they make their arguments to jurors.
THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP's earlier story is below.
A judge said Wednesday he expects to let prosecutors play for jurors at trial next week the only recording of a phone call between a former Goldman Sachs board member accused of insider trading and a hedge fund founder.
U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff made the tentative ruling at a hearing before the trial of Rajat Gupta begins with jury selection Monday. Gupta was a board member at Goldman Sachs and Procter & Gamble when the government said he gave tips in 2008 to billionaire hedge-fund trading friend, Raj Rajaratnam. Gupta's lawyers say he did not.
Prosecutors plan to play a 24-minute recording of a July 2008 conversation in which Gupta discussed Goldman Sachs' plans with Rajaratnam, who founded the Galleon Group of hedge funds. Defense lawyers argued that the information was already public. It is the only recording between the men that relates to the charges.
The taped conversation carries added significance because prosecutors have relied on wiretaps in their prosecution of Rajaratnam and more than two dozen others in a wide ranging probe of insider trading in the hedge fund industry. U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara has said it was the most extensive use of wiretaps ever in an insider trading investigation.
After he was convicted at trial, Rajaratnam began serving an 11-year prison sentence, the longest ever given in an insider trading case. Others charged in the probe, including workers at public companies who shared tips with money managers, have pleaded guilty or been convicted at trial.
Gupta, 63, of Westport, Conn., has pleaded not guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit securities fraud and five counts of securities fraud, charges that carry a potential penalty of 105 years in prison. He remains free on $10 million bail.
At Wednesday's hearing, Assistant U.S. Attorney Reed Brodsky promised that in its arguments to jurors, "you won't hear the government use the word `greed.'"
He was responding to arguments by Gupta's lawyer, Gary Naftalis, who said it was necessary to tell the jury about his client's impressive charitable work to counter the government's depiction of him as being obsessed with money.
"He's done all these wonderful things. And they would say that one day out of a clear blue sky in the seventh decade of his life, he decides to become a criminal," Naftalis said.
He said he believed the government was prepared to show jurors "a false and misleading picture" of a man who devoted at least half of his time to charitable causes.
The judge said a quick reference to charitable works could be mentioned if Gupta testifies. Naftalis refused to divulge whether he will.
(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)
Proposal to rename Soap Lake is deferred
There won't be a quick decision on a strongly debated proposal to change the name of central Washington's Soap Lake to Lake Smokiam.- Alaska restaurant battles Seattle for first fish
- Rockies managed 2 hits in 4-0 loss to Mariners.
- Mariners 4, Rockies 0
- New police chief for Sunriver, Ore.
- Man dead after small boat overturns in WA waters
- Soldier faces murder charges in Iraq base deaths
- GOP's top budget writer in state Senate to retire
- More Local News »
What rhymes with marijuana?
Bill Radke rhymes the news... from Monday to Friday it's the week in a nutshell. - Ross & Burbank: Video: Who can eat the most cheeseburgers in 3 minutes?
- Ross & Burbank: Video: Who can eat the most cheeseburgers in 3 minutes?
- Monson: Dori gets his own hot dog, the Dori Dog
- TBTL: So This Also Happened...
- mynw: John Curley auctions off in-studio KIRO experiences
- Radke: What rhymes with marijuana?
-

The official Dori Monson PoDog
Dori Monson unveils his very own PoDog for "Experience:... -
Rachel Belle's Dick's cheeseburger eating challenge
Rachel Belle, Sean De Tore, Luke Burbank, and Libby... -

Inside Seattle Center's new Chihuly museum
The new, permanent 1.5 acre exhibit is located near... -

Week in photos
Stars at Cannes, poodle in sunglasses, Michael Phelps...
Debating the merits of the Seahawks' QB approach
Mike Salk explains why he disagrees with a national writer's contention that Pete Carroll and the Seahawks have gone about their search for a quarterback the wrong way. - Drayer: Is it time for the gloves to come off?
- Blue 42: Huskies have work to do up front
- Sounders renew rivalry with Whitecaps
- Audio: Baldwin impressed by Russell Wilson
- Audio: Sark on O-line, backup QB options
- Vilma sues Goodell for defamation
- More proof Marshawn Lynch is one of a kind
- More Sports »
Feds say Colorado wildfire started on camp stove
Hundreds of firefighters are battling a blaze fueled by warm, dry weather in northern Colorado that federal officials say started with a camp stove. - 3 charged with terror conspiracy ahead of NATO
- LA police arrest 2 in killings of Chinese students
- 3 NATO protesters face terror conspiracy charges
- Jurors in Edwards trial will resume talks Monday
- Amid apparent rift, kin mourn Mary Kennedy
- Jokes and sympathy _ Obama greets his G-8 guests
- Pilot dies in military trainer jet crash in Calif.
- More National News »
Probation for builder of Calif.'s Phonehenge West
The man who built an eccentric Mojave Desert compound known as Phonehenge West was placed on five years' probation on Friday and ordered to serve 63 days community service, five of them at the county morgue. - Man wears briefs on head during Idaho burglary
- Moose on the loose triggers police chase in Utah
- Police on swallowed diamond: This, too, shall pass
- Authorities: Trooper gets text seeking illegal buy
- Arizona man suing Flagstaff is now its mayor
- Horse runs into sea, rescued a mile offshore
- Workers go trash-picking for Mass. woman's rings
- More Odd News »


